Good Friday. Where are you, God? April 15, 2022, St. Mark’s noon
All of Little Rock mourns the death of award-winning photojournalist Brent Renaud, gunned down in Irpin, on the outskirts of Kyiv, documenting the plight of fleeing Ukrainian refugees. Americans, especially Arkansans, cry out, “Where are you, God? Why did you let this happen?”
Tetiana Pere/by/in/is, an accountant, gardener, and avid skier, and her two daughters, /18-year-old Mykyta and 9-year-old Alisa,/ along with Anatoly Berezh/nyi, a 26-year-old church volunteer helping them to safety,/ didn’t make it. On a Sunday, they were also killed in Irpin, trying to evacuate, as they dashed across the concrete remnants of a damaged bridge. 1 The Ukrainian people cry out, “Where are you, God, in the midst of this bloody Ukrainian invasion?” 1/
Over 80 years earlier, Ellie Wie/sel, a Romanian Holocaust survivor, describes a scene at his concentration camp, Auschwitz. “The SS hang two Jewish men and a boy before the assembled inhabitants of the camp. The men die quickly, but the death struggle of the boy lasts half an hour. “Where is God? Where is he?” a man behind Wie/sel asks. After a long time, as the boy is still in agony on the rope, Wiesel hears the man cry again, “Where is God now?” And Wiesel hears a voice within him answer, “Here God is—he is hanging here on this gallows” suffering with the young boy…. 2//
On Good Friday, we bring our grief to this place, mourning others who have died, as we contemplate the why of Jesus’ death. We linger at this cross for a few uncomfortable moments. It is a reality. Jesus died. Like others, it is a profoundly unjust, sometimes overwhelmingly painful death, and we need one day more to deal with it. Probably more than one, actually. We stand on top of Gol/go/tha to decide what Jesus’ death means to each of us? How should all these deaths, but particularly the death of Jesus, make some sense of our living and our dying.3 /
The stark rawness of today does not bring many answers.
Of all the world’s religions, Christianity is the only one that has a God who suffers, who knows, has experienced firsthand our own pain. He is a suffering servant, which no one had ever heard of before. Jesus means to transform the world by loving it, not by controlling it, which makes his life hell most of the time. No other world religions have a leader who dies suffering. Buddha dies at eighty, surrounded by his followers. Confucius dies an old man putting together ancient Chinese writings. Muhammad dies in the arms of his favorite wife while he is the ruler of Arabia. Jesus is not so fortunate. But his suffering does make him our best company/when we run into our own bad times. He has been there. There is nothing that hurts us that he does not know about. At our most broken, our most frightened, our most forsaken by God, we have this companion who has been there and promises to be there with us. There he lives, sitting beside and inside us in the lowest places in our lives. Nothing we think or do can shock him. Nothing we say can make him turn away. If we say, “Where are you, God? I’m all alone here,” HE also said it from the cross, / as Mark and Matthew tell us. Good Friday shows us that the Christian faith has nothing to do with the removal of suffering. Instead, we are given a God who intimately knows our pain and agrees to suffer with us/and for us.4 This is love that crosses all boundaries.
Jesus’ death may be beyond comprehension, but it is not beyond belief. We may later find it smack dab in the middle of our belief in life beyond death, ushered in by the humble death of this suffering servant./
Perhaps if we continue our window into the scenes of Good Friday, where Michael led us on Palm Sunday, actually placing ourselves on that hill, we may find answers/.
We come closer and hear Jesus’ first words from the cross recorded in John./ Jesus never observes our suffering from a distance, so we, in turn, must move even nearer to him. Jesus says to his mother: “Woman, here is your son.” And to the disciple, “Here is your mother.” Barbara Brown Taylor5 believes that when the beloved disciple takes Mary home, and when the other disciples crawl out from under their rocks, they will find themselves in the presence of two people whose contact with God’s love has become far more intimate than theirs. While the principalities and powers in Jerusalem believe they are tearing his family apart, Jesus lovingly is quietly putting it together again. My experience is also that Jesus constantly does this for us. When our sister or brother or mother or father or child is physically separated from us by death, Jesus gives us a new and different loving relationship with them/and others, if only we have eyes and ears to see/ and hear/ and believe/ and accept it./
On Good Friday, so much focus is rightfully on Jesus’ suffering on the cross. But as we stand below Jesus, we see next to us the courageous women of John’s story, Mary, her sister, and the woman from Magdala. To honor them, we pray for other women who now weep for their children, refusing to be comforted. We hold in prayer similar women standing on today’s Golgotha, who, in the face of horrible suffering, somehow find strength to hold each other up.” 6//
Jesus’ last words we hear are “IT IS FINISHED.”
But is Jesus’ crucifixion indeed finished that afternoon 2000 years ago?/ We gather here at St. Mark’s because we are an Easter people, but our world is still more like Good Friday. Do we continue to be active observers and participants in Christ’s crucifixion still going on today?3/
There is no lethal injection in Jesus’ time. The whole point is to make everything as painful as possible. As we stand so close to that cross today, we agree that crucifixion is the worst.
As we look up at the wounded crucified Jesus, we recognize that he has become what we most fear: nakedness, exposure, vulnerability, and failure.7 We listen, but hear only silence from the God of our understanding. We receive few direct answers. We suffer in silence with the crucified one, wondering what is God’s meaning in all this. Perhaps we can connect to God’s love so immense that we now know God suffers with us. 8 //
It will be dark by the time we help take Jesus’ torn, naked body down from the cross and find a place to lay him. It will be the Sabbath. His time to rest. His part is over. His work is done.9 Some will tell us that Jesus is brutally crucified so that we might see the horror of it all and cease crucifying others like Brent, Tetiana, Mykyta, Alisa, Ana/to/ly.7/ Will it ever end?/
We will go home and prepare for the Sabbath. It will be hard to say our prayers.
“God, where are you? We desperately want answers./ But we are not yet giving up on you, God./ Your history with us tells us that you have continually redeemed evil and turned it into good since time began. But this horrific event is too dark. Where can there be good in this Friday?”10/
We will finally fall asleep, but out of respect for you, God, plan to come back, continuing our Holy Week walk together, hoping to find any answer. / We will return to this place near sundown tomorrow,/ or at least the following day.
Joanna Seibert
1 Andrew Kramer, “They died by a bridge in Ukraine. This is My Story,” New York Times March 9, 2022.
2 Elie Wiesel in Night (Night Trilogy) (Hill and Wang January 2006).
3Julian DeShazier in Christian Century, March 23, 2016.
4 Barbara Brown Taylor, “The Suffering of God,” God in Pain (Abingdon 1998) pp. 120-124.
5 Barbara Brown Taylor, “Mother of the New,” Home By Another Way, pp. 97-99.
6 Eileen D. Crowley, “Sunday’s Coming,” Christian Century April 11, 2017.
7 Adapted from Richard Rohr, On Transformation: Collected Talks (Franciscan Media: 1997), disc 1 (CD).
8 Barbara Brown Taylor, “The Silence of God,” God in Pain (Abingdon 1998) pp. 110-114.
9 Barbara Brown Taylor, “It is Finished,” Home By Another Way (Cowley 1999) pp. 103-105.
10 Frederick Buechner in Wishful Thinking.