Epiphany 5C. Call of Peter
February 6, 2022
Luke 5:1-11 St. Mark’s
“Hello, yes, this is Mrs. Simon Peter. What! My husband has not been at the docks for two weeks! His boat is filled to the brim with dead, rotting fish! You are going to confiscate our boat! And the boat of his partners as well! Could you give me a little time to look into this? I have been taking care of my mother, who has a recurrent febrile illness, and we have just started building a new home in Capernaum.”
Do you ever wonder what is really going on between the lines of this familiar story about the call of the first disciples? There is often more that is not said than what is said. For centuries, students of the Hebrew scriptures have been trying to fill in the blanks, the conversational details. This is called midrash, and that is what we are doing this morning to Luke’s version of the story of “the catch of the day.”
Peter and his brother Andrew are in the family fishing business, in partnership with Zebedee and his sons, James and John. They have all been intrigued by the teachings of this new itinerant preacher. Jesus has even come to Peter’s home for dinner and miraculously healed his mother-in-law so that she can serve dinner. This particular morning, a huge crowd is following Jesus along the shores of the Sea of Galilee. Peter and his partners, however, are out trying to make a living and haven’t had the luxury of free time to spend with Jesus. They have been fishing all night with no results. As they pull into shore, they are running their bruised, tired hands along miles of worn wet netting to tighten knots and take in the slack of frayed cords. They are hungry, tired, and want to go home.
Jesus then spies his dinner partners and asks if he might use their boat for a pulpit for his impending sermon. Of course, Peter cannot refuse the one who has just healed a family member, especially in front of all these people; but this interruption is not what Peter has on his agenda or even his radar screen. Peter nods his head, but grumbles under his breathe while Jesus gets into his boat and begins to preach. Luke doesn’t tell us anything about Jesus’ sermon. Perhaps it is his first draft of the Sermon on the Mount or an early version of his series on the Lost Sheep, the Lost Coin, and the Lost Son. Poor Peter now has yet another job trying to keep the boat in place offshore while Jesus speaks. There is no indication that he listens to the sermon, for it probably takes every bit of his last energy to steady the boat off shore, work the live stream sound system, so that the crowd can now hear more clearly the voice of Jesus magnified from a cove in the lake. Finally, after about an hour, Jesus finishes. It is now midday. Jesus then shows us his flexibility, how he lives continuously in the present moment. He sees Peter’s fatigue and frustration. Jesus senses that Peter needs fish, not words. So he tells him to go out into deeper water and put down his cleaned nets and fish again.
“What in the world is he saying? We have tried that before, and it doesn’t work. Everyone in first-century Palestine knows you fish in deep water at night.” Peter is a professional fisherman who knows this lake like the back of his hand. Jesus is a carpenter turned teacher. Well, you know what Peter is tempted to say, but exhausted, Peter does as he is told, hoping that he will eventually get to go home. And then, to his amazement, he catches extreme abundance, more fish that he and his partners can bring in or their boats can hold. Finally, exhausted and overwhelmed, Peter falls to his knees in a sinking boat full of flipping fish and confesses to Jesus that he was so wrong. Peter is ready to turn his life and his will over to Jesus. And Jesus’ answer is even more astonishing: “Do not be afraid, from now on you will be catching people.” When they come to shore, Peter and his partners have changed their priorities about fishing, and leave their boats and follow Jesus.
All of us desperately want to know what it is like to be Peter, to be called by and hear the voice of God, or we would not be here in this place. Today, Luke clearly tells us what that call looks and sounds and smells like.
Where is Peter, and what is he doing when he is called? Peter is not doing anything particularly religious when he has his life-changing spiritual experience. He is not following Jesus, but is busy trying to make a living at his workplace. We may hear God call us in this church, but we are more likely to hear that voice in our everyday lives, at home, school, and work.
My experience also is that this call will come in an interruption from our routine. So pay very close attention to the interruptions that come when you are much too busy for them: people and places that are not scheduled on your desktop or Google Calendar.
God also comes to us where WE are. Luke tells us that Jesus begins his ministry in synagogues, but he doesn’t call his disciples by putting an ad in the Galilee Hebrew Democrat-Gazette saying, “Local teacher needs staff. No experience necessary.”/ Instead, Jesus makes personal appearances at the homes and workplaces of those he calls.
What do you think motivates Peter to go out into deeper water and try a new way of fishing? My experience is that we only make these life-changing decisions when we are like Peter, exhausted by how our life is going, when we are “sick and tired of being sick and tired.”/ We hit a bottom and have no more answers. One of our children gets into trouble, and we cannot fix it this time; our spouse is sick and is not getting better; we lose our job and have difficulty finding another one. Suddenly we are open to a memory from childhood, a conversation with a stranger or an old friend. We read a scripture passage again, or see an old movie like “Field of Dreams” or “A River Runs Through It,” or “Places in the Heart,” and it is as if we are hearing and seeing it for the first time. And God comes to us/ and transforms us/ in the ordinary, small kindnesses and acts of self-sacrifice from strangers, family members, friends,/ even simply from a child’s smile,/ and our nets are filled to overflowing in ordinary ways. //
Have you wondered why Peter’s confession of his humanity, his shortcomings, his inability to be in control is so essential to his call? Fishing is Peter’s talent. He must recognize the source of that talent and who gives him the direction to make the catch. Part of Peter’s greatness is this ability to surrender and see his own powerlessness. But that same power that causes him to fall on his knees also lifts him up. Jesus says to him, “Fine, now we are ready to get to work. If you hadn’t been able to see and confess your true self,/ you would be no good to anyone.”
What does Jesus mean by telling Peter he will now be catching people instead of fish? Is he saying Peter should now give up fishing? My experience is that God uses the talents we have perfected in our worldly vocations for his purposes. Peter’s skills in fishing will now be used for the kingdom. Nothing, nothing is ever wasted. Fishing may now be the best way Peter will meet others seeking the Christ, just as Jesus first met Peter at his workplace.
Many of you know better than I the skills you learn at fishing and hunting that can be used to further the kingdom: patience; working in community; putting out a net, a feeler, a fishing line, to find something utterly unknown beneath the surface of your life; becoming an artist, seeing God’s presence in nature, feeling God’s pleasure in the sun and wind on your face and the salt in your hair, being constantly surrounded by images in a natural world more significant than yourself. This is where Peter finds God in his ordinary life, as we can as well.
One last thought to ponder. Isn’t it also interesting that none of the disciples Jesus chooses are from the religious community of his day? Instead, all of his followers are people called to a second career, people seeing their present occupations in a new light.
So, this is the call. Do you hear it? God is calling each of us, most of us a bunch of rank amateurs, who don’t know a trout from a salmon or who can’t distinguish port from starboard./ We are not called because WE are able,/ but because God is able. God constantly gets into the boat with us,/ usually at odd and inconvenient times, /leading us and going with us to deeper waters where our nets will be filled to the brim.
Joanna joannaseibert.com